BZA Rules on Truck Stop: Yes and No
by Leslie Lytle, Messenger Staff Writer
In a two-motion vote at the Nov. 13 meeting, the Monteagle Board of Zoning Appeals in part affirmed and in part denied that Monteagle Building Inspector Travis Lawyer acted within his authority in recent actions taken which, ultimately, allowed work on the long-contested Petro Travel Center to proceed. Resident Billy Best maintained Lawyer issued a building permit on “a dead site plan” that was never officially approved.
Best’s argument hinged on two points. One, a building permit was issued “in error” for the Petro-project site plan approved conditionally in 2021, since the planning commission never received and signed a revised site plan addressing the three outstanding conditions. Monteagle code stipulates the planning commission secretary must sign a site plan to certify it is complete before the building inspector issues a building permit. Two, the vested property rights of the project had expired because the developers did not meet benchmarks toward completion within a three-year time frame beginning when the site plan was conditionally approved. Best cited the Monteagle Council August 2024 resolution revoking the project’s vested property rights. When challenged in court, the chancellor ruled the council acted “in an arbitrary and capricious manner,” ruling in favor of the truck stop developers, without offering an opinion on whether the vested rights should continue. “The question remains unresolved,” Best stressed.
“The vested rights are not their call,” countered Monteagle attorney Sam Elliott. BZA chair Jeff O’Neal agreed, “We can’t rule on vested rights. The only thing we can rule on is whether our officer acted right or wrong in the matter.”
“I’m not asking you to assume misconduct,” Best said, “but to acknowledge inconsistencies.”
“Everything Billy told you is right,” Lawyer said.
In late summer, after the project sold to the new owner Saffron, Lawyer issued a stop work order since Saffron had not submitted a revised site plan addressing the three conditions. When Lawyer subsequently received drawings addressing the three landscaping and lighting issues, he lifted the stop work order and issued a building permit.
Monteagle code gives the building inspector authority to approve site plan changes. On those grounds, BZA member Nate Wilson made a motion “Travis Lawyer acted within his authority to approve revisions to the 2021 site plan to move it from conditional to final status.”
The BZA approved the motion except for Dede Clements. Lawyer acknowledges he never presented a revised site plan to the planning commission for final review and the secretary’s signature. Asked why, Lawyer said, “Because it was going before the BZA.”
The BZA unanimously approved a second motion: “The current building permit was issued in error because the revised site plan as approved by Travis Lawyer did not have the signature of the secretary of the planning commission.”
In closing, O’Neal observed, “We don’t have the right to prescribe a remedy.”