University Opposes Pipeline: The Next Steps?
by Leslie Lytle, Messenger Staff Writer
“The University passing this resolution in opposition to the pipeline sends a loud and clear statement to the company Kinder Morgan (KM) that this is going to be difficult,” said University biology professor Jon Evans at a Nov. 17 student town meeting at Biehl Commons to educate the community and rally opposition to the proposed Kinder Morgan Southeast Connector Natural Gas Pipeline which would travel through two miles of University land, for a total of 14 miles in Franklin County. “Time is money for Kinder Morgan. This is a delay. They have to deal with the PR issues, the legal issues, and this large institution’s opposition. They may say, ‘It’s just not worth it,’ and make alternative decisions. That’s what we’re hoping for,” Evans stressed. Earlier the same day, the faculty endorsed the resolution opposing the pipeline passed by the Strategic Planning Committee the previous Friday. The resolution calls for five action items: notify the company of the University’s opposition; analyze the pipeline’s impact and alternative routes; coordinate efforts with other impacted landowners, especially St. Andrew’s-Sewanee School, and with elected officials; communicate the University’s position to community residents and leaseholders; and, issue a public statement opposing the pipeline and stating why. Asked when the public statement would be forthcoming, Vice Chancellor Rob Pearigen said, “I hope soon. We’re working with our legal counsel to develop a strategy. The strategy has to come before the statement. There is still a lot we don’t know.”
The proposed 150-mile pipeline will connect a KM pipeline on the Tennessee-Kentucky border with a KM pipeline in north Alabama travelling to north central Georgia. KM has not released a plottable map. But according to Evans, a coalition of impacted landowners has plotted the Franklin County route by identifying landowners who received letters notifying them of KM’s intentions and requesting to survey the property. What is not known is where the gas is going and who needs it. “The pipeline is a connector,” Evans said. “It doesn’t leave the pipe in Tennessee.” TVA is the largest public utility in Tennessee and the supplier for Duck River Electric and the other area electricity providers. The Southeast Connector Pipeline is “not on TVA’s radar screen yet,” a Duck River Electric board member told Evans. “This is not gas for your kitchen to fry an egg. It is gas specially formulated for public or private power plants to generate electricity,” Evans said. “But current studies of TVA indicate middle Tennessee is not in need of new supplies of power. There is a huge demand for power in data centers all around the country [to facilitate the AI boom]. But there are no data centers planned, publicly, for middle Tennessee.”
If the project is approved by the Federal Energy Regulatory Commission, KM has the authority to exercise “eminent domain” and construct the pipeline through opposing landowners’ property “for the public good.” “What is the public good in this context?” Evans asked. “Taking land for profit providing fuel for we don’t know what. To generate electricity for a data center in Atlanta?”
What is known? Evans cited statistics: the proposed 48” diameter pipeline is the largest pipeline configuration in use in North America; KM is the largest pipeline company in North America; and the University is the most important and largest impacted landowner in the state. Evans speculated the “substantial obstacle” the University could pose drove the KM decision to locate the project's primary office in Winchester.
Evans reiterated the devastating environmental consequences that would be inflicted on old growth forests, wetlands, and endangered species by the 125’ wide “destruction zone” required for construction. University student Silvie Chandler, raised on a Virginia mountaintop, talked about growing up with a pipeline being constructed through her family’s and neighbors’ property, despite their objections. The deforestation led to runoff, flooding, and roads washing away. “It’s not over,” Chandler said. “We’re still living with the fallout. The land is changed forever.” Reforestation of the land is not allowed. The company controls the land they have an easement on. “It’s no longer your land,” Chandler observed, “but you still pay property taxes on it.”
For some of the landowners in Chandler’s remote Virginia community, the blasting contaminated drinking water wells and livestock died as a result. And, yes, the Franklin County section of pipeline would require blasting, Evans confirmed, in order to create the eight-foot deep trench needed to bury the pipeline in the bedrock substructure of the mountain terrain.
Verifying concerns about explosions from ruptures to the pipeline, Evans said, in industry jargon, the “blast zone” identifies the half-mile radius within which everything would be incinerated. Ruptures were frequent. In one incident, where the home was 400’ from the pipeline, two people were killed. “We don’t have the capacity to deal with an explosion,” a member of the Sewanee Volunteer Fire Department confided to Evans. Along the Franklin County route, there are homes within 100 feet of the proposed right of way. And in drought conditions like the Plateau is currently experiencing, fire from an explosion could sweep across 1,000 of acres.
Plans tentatively call for a Compressor Station in Roark’s Cove to move the gas, with one needed every 40-50 miles. Landowner and Roark’s Cove resident James Stephens compared the 25-30 acre facility to an “industrial complex.” “There couldn’t be a worse place for a compressor station,” Stephens insisted, pointing to damage to the pristine aesthetics and environment and the ongoing “low rumble” noise generated by the facilities.
Stephens also called attention to the pipeline targeting rural areas, where low-income landowners struggling with hard times, and Christmas just a month away, could be tempted by the $500 offered by KM for allowing a survey.
Pearigen expressed concern about an alternative route shifting the problem to others. “We hope others say, no, too,” Evans said, suggesting the Franklin County opposition effort could function as a “clearing house” for sharing ideas and support.
Asked how local residents could assist in the “stop the pipeline” effort, Evans advised signing the petition and contacting elected officials. The county commission will vote on a resolution opposing the pipeline in January. Senator Janice Bowling has expressed strong opposition to the pipeline. Conversely, Evans understood Governor Lee’s position to be that it was not his role to get involved in negotiations between the company and landowners. For those who want to take direct action, Evans recommended reaching out to Statewide Organizing for Community eMpowerment (SOCM). As coordinators of the local opposition movement, SOCM is planning and directing volunteer opposition efforts. Go to <https://www.nopipelinetn.com> for more information.
Stephens offered an additional way to foster the hoped for change of plans. “The next time you do a Google search,” Stephens said, “consider not using AI.”